All-New Short Story Comics, published by Harvey Comics, ran for three issues in 1943. It then shortened its title to All-New Comics and ran for another sporatic 11 issues, finishing up for good in 1947.
The first issue (January 1943) includes the only story featuring newspaper reporter Steve Case. The writer is unknown. The artist is Harry Sahle (who often signed his work with just his last name). Sahle had a respectable career as a comic book artist in the 1940s, working for Harvey, Timely and Archie. His work is fun to look at, bristling with kinetic energy and featuring eye-catching character designs.
"Poison Pen Murder" begins with Steve and his editor meeting with two ex-cons. One of the ex-cons has written a story about his time in prison. He's delivering the manuscript. Also, he and his companion, Big Mike Scorey, have to sign a release.
But the author dies suddenly just when he's about to sign.
Steve suspects murder and scraps some dried ink from the dead guy's fingers. But outside the office, he's jumped by a big guy. (One can argue there's not much of a mystery here. The big guy is masked, but he's the exact same build as Big Mike.) Steve drives off his attacker and sees that the guy has dropped a pen. He brings this to the police lab as well.
Sure enough, the ink in the pen is loaded with poison that can be absorped through skin pores. Steve realizes the killer wants to stop the manuscript from being published. Rushing to his editor's home, he stops the killer from obtaining the manuscript. The killer, though, escapes. Steve is really good at punching people, but he's apparently weak on following up on his punches.
It doesn't matter, though. Steve has also noticed the killer is the same build as Big Mike, so he uses the poison pen to scare a confession from him. The manuscript contained information that would have sent Big Mike back to jail.
Which makes you wonder why the manuscript's author brought Big Mike with him to the newspaper as if the two were best buddies.
The mystery is a very simple one, but that's to be expected in a six page tale. It's Sahle's kinetic art that makes it work. And, though we never get to see Steve Case work another case, "Poison Pen Murder" was reprinted in Super-Dooper Comics in 1947 and in Golden Age Greats Spotlight iin 2018. So Steve has managed to poke his head out of Comic Book Limbo a couple of times.
You can read the story online HERE.
Next week, we'll look at the one and only issue of Marvel's Western Team-Up.